Explore Companies BySectors & Categories
Explore Companies ByUse Cases
Explore Companies ByProducts & Services
Explore Companies ByRankings & Reviews
Featured NewsCompaniesMarketsCryptoTechRegulatoryCommentaryUKUSWorldMore

    Latest Wires

      Daily Newsletter

      LF Daily News

      Daily industry focused newsletter giving you an overview for the financial & finTech industry.

      See All Newsletters
      By clicking "Sign Up" you are agreeing to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

      ADVANCED MARKETS BLOG: Moment of Truth: ESMA requires the publication of RTS27 & RTS28 reports

      Published: just now

      ADVANCED MARKETS BLOG: Moment of Truth: ESMA requires the publication of RTS27 & RTS28 reports

      The inner workings of brokers have always been a mystery, a secret more closely guarded than the gates of hell it seems. That makes one wonder, why is it such a well-kept secret and what is there to hide? There are many underlying reasons:



            ○  Most brokers source their liquidity deals from the same counterparties as their competitors and, if disclosed, it opens a whole new can of worms in terms of the different pricing each one receives from their LPs. It's no secret that the OTC FX market is heavily relationship-based and therefore everyone doesn’t get the same price.

            ○  There is somewhat of a dissonance between the marketing narrative and actual actions of the business. Typical marketing campaigns highlight catchphrases such as “no conflict of interest”, “STP”, “ECN”, “no dealing desk”, but the reality can often be very different. The majority of retail, margin brokers have no access to credit and often do not pass their client trades to Tier1 banks or institutional counterparts for execution, despite what their advertising may suggest.

            ○  Many brokers contract with liquidity counterparties while seemingly circumventing the rules prescribed by MiFID 2 under the best execution clause. They would rather go with those entities who are promising financial incentives, in some cases choosing to prioritize the monetization of their flow over the safety of client funds and the quality of trade execution. However, with the push for transparency from ESMA, brokers are finally being forced to let the cat out of the bag and disclose this sensitive information. The results are mind-blowing.

      The majority of brokers are not reporting



      As reported by Cappitech, a reg tech firm in the UK, many brokers are not producing RTS 27 reports and 60% have no intention to use the reports on execution quality internally. That is despite the fact that ESMA has recently issued a Q&A clarification to MiFID 2 that clearly mandates that the RTS 27 report should be published quarterly, and RTS 28 annually, with no longer than 3 months delay.

      Financial firms must keep these reports in the public domain and it “should not be placed behind a firewall, registration page or be subject to password encryption or other restrictions”. Reports must be kept online for 2 years

      Many show counterparties as their own affiliate entities overseas

      Many brokers show that 100% of their flow is funneled to their own subsidiaries in other countries, which is an “OK” thing to do as long as the client can check reports for the destination entity overseas. Alas, that is only possible if an affiliate entity is within the EU. If not, good luck finding an RTS 28 report for a company in a less-than-stringent regulatory jurisdiction.

      Many reports show results that are contrary to advertised practices

      While a firm’s sales team might be telling the story about what banks and institutions lie behind their trade execution facility, the reality, revealed by these RTS 28 reports, is that many are warehousing 100% of the flow (internalizing the risk) and not sending it to the market. It could perhaps be that while pricing is somehow derived from the interbank market, the trade execution itself is internalized within the firm.

      By the way, it can be difficult to find the RTS reports on a firm’s website, as they are not often prominently situated, but you can locate these by simply searching “Broker name + RTS” in Google or going under “legal documents” or the equivalent section on a regulated broker’s website.

      While there has been much moaning about the complexity of the new regulations and increased compliance costs, it does indeed finally provide a degree of transparency to clients of these firms, allowing them to assess risks and to make their own educated decisions. I am impressed by the very detailed Q&A document recently published by ESMA , especially with the concrete guidance that is provided. Increasing transparency will be an important factor in the future success of the margin FX sector.

      Sources: https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/library/esma35-43-349_mifid_ii_qas_on_investor_protection_topics.pdf https://www.thetradenews.com/half-firms-not-producing-mifid-ii-rts-27-best-ex-reports/

      We're the largest marketplace to connect with brokers, Fintech companies & digital asset firms. Want to partner? Let's get in touch.

      This content may have been written by a third party. LiquidityFinder makes no representation or warranty and assumes no liability as to the accuracy or completeness of the information provided, nor any loss arising from any investment based on a recommendation, forecast or other information supplies by any third-party. This content is information only, and does not constitute financial, investment or other advice on which you can rely.
      Comments
      Most Recent
      Written By
      profile image formember on LiquidityFinder
      Founder & CEO, LiquidityFinder

      Sam Low is the founder and CEO of LiquidityFinder. He has more than 25 years of experience in financial markets technology and is building a professional network and marketplace for the financial industry.

      Daily Newsletter

      LF Daily News

      Daily industry focused newsletter giving you an overview for the financial & finTech industry.

      See All Newsletters
      By clicking "Sign Up" you are agreeing to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
      RSS Feeds

      Create a custom RSS Feed

      Select the categories and companies you wish to follow directly to your person rss feed.

      Create Custom RSS Feed

      Related Categories:

      Related Tags:

      #ESMA#RTS27RTS28#MiFID2#BestExecution#ExecutionQuality#LiquidityProviders#Cappitech#TransparencyRequirements

      Related Articles:

      Find The Right Partners for
      Your Trading Business

      Sign up and join over 5,000 professional members who receive personalized news alerts, curated professional connections, and more for free!

      Create Your FREE Account
      Get access to latest news, updates, real-time data, brokerage and trading firm insights and customized information feeds.

      Brokers can offer LMAX perpetual futures alongside FX and CFDs through a single trading account. LMAX says brokers with existing credentials can go live in under five days.

      just now

      24X National Exchange has filed a proposed rule change with the SEC to launch 24X Options, a general options market trading from 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. ET. The filing also covers binary KPI options on quarterly revenue, earnings per share and other metrics for 23 of the most actively traded U.S. companies.

      just now

      cTrader Mobile 5.11 introduces Signals, a new app where traders can browse signals from leading providers and act on them directly in the platform.

      just now

      ATFX Group has partnered with South Africa-based payment and digital asset infrastructure provider FiveWest to support institutional fund movements for ATFX Connect and add a cryptocurrency funding option for eligible retail clients. Both firms hold FSCA Over-the-Counter Derivative Provider licences.

      just now

      UK inflation rose to 3.6% in October, keeping a December Bank of England rate rise likely, while the euro hit a fresh one-year low against the dollar ahead of tonight’s Fed minutes. Daily FX analysis from Equals.

      just now

      GBPUSD has shifted decisively lower. After reaching 1.3228, the pair reversed and initially consolidated around the moving averages before breaking sharply below the 1.3180 area. It is now trading near 1.3169.

      just now

      Nvidia shares jumped around 4% after hours after beating earnings and revenue expectations and raising its outlook for 75% year on year revenue growth through January 2028. The positive Nvidia results also lifted AI-related stocks, with CoreWeave up 8% and Nebius 10%.

      just now

      Deutsche Börse Group has appointed Maximilian Weissenrieder as Head of Cash Market from 1 January 2027, succeeding Eric Leupold, who becomes CEO of Eurex. Weissenrieder has led Group M&A and Venture Investments since October 2024 and will retain those duties until a successor is named by the Group.

      just now

      DEXA, the AI-powered risk management and analytics platform developed by TFB (Tools for Brokers), has connected with Match-Trader, bringing real-time trader analysis and toxic flow detection to brokers on the platform. DEXA classifies trader behaviour from as early as the third trade, with no change to execution systems.

      just now

      Poland's financial markets regulator, the Polish Financial Supervision Authority (Komisja Nadzoru Finansowego, KNF), is preparing a new product intervention on contracts for difference (CFDs)

      just now
      Feed